A ‘Capital’ Idea

Kneejerk reaction to Trump’s ‘Jerusalem recognition’ of Israel’s capital, smacks less of concern for the pursuit of peace and more an exposé of anti-Semitism

Amazing, the world seldom agrees with each other on any issue, but when it comes to Israel, they unite WITHIN MINUTESagainst.

Its instinctive; its reflexive; its vile and its anti-Semitic.

Israel stands alone as the world’s dartboard. Even North Korea, poised to literally ‘inflame’ the world with nuclear war, does not solicit such instant global opprobrium!!

President Donald Trump had hardly finished completing his announcement on the USA recognising Jerusalem as Israel’s capital – deliberately emphasizing that he was not endorsing borders or boundaries, leaving that for the parties to determine – when Muslims around the world were reaching out for their matches to ignite ready-made Israeli and US flags.

They were literally inflaming hatred.

Sad, but hardly unexpected.

But then, within minutes of Trump leaving the podium at the White House, enter world leaders from the UK, France, Germany, and the Vatican who were proverbially tripping over each other to distance and denounce. Aggressively jumping off the starting block from the Muslim world was Turkey’s autocratic President, Recep Tayyip Erdogan calling Jerusalem a “red line for Muslims” and warning “we could go as far as cutting diplomatic ties with Israel over this issue.”

The Israeli Knesset

The Israeli Parliament (Knesset) in Jerusalem

Over what issue – that Israel’s capital Jerusalem is Israel’s capital?

When is a capital not a capital?

It defies logic.

When foreign statesmen and dignitaries from abroad visit Israel, they do not meet to discuss and negotiate at a falafel joint or beachfront cafeteria in Tel Aviv! They meet in Jerusalem – the home of Israel’s Knesset (Parliament), Supreme Court, the Bank of Israel, all government ministries, the Presidents and Prime Minister’s residences and the final resting place of Israel’s stateman.

Every visiting statesman, without exception, pays tribute to the six million Jews martyred during the Holocaust at ‘Yad Vashem’ (Israel’s national Holocaust Memorial and Museum) situated on Mt. Zion in Jerusalem.

When Egyptian President Anwar Sadat and King Hussein of Jordan visited Israel, they addressed the people of Israel not from the football stadium in Ramat Gan but the Knesset in Jerusalem with the entire world watching.

They recognized the symbolic significance of connecting with Israelis and where better than from a podium in the legislature of the country’s CAPITAL.

So why the rage?

OutRAGEous

The pundits and political commentators on all TV news networks rushed to regurgitate the same fallacious argument, stressing three points of Trump’s announcement:

  • Showed bias
  • The US can no longer act as an honest broker
  • Rewarding Israel would be prejudging the status of Jerusalem

All nonsense!

If most the world genuinely believed the US “is biased”, “unable to continue as an honest broker”, and has “prejudged the status of Jerusalem” what does it say about most of the countries of the world whose representatives to the United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) overwhelmingly passed a resolution in April 2016, negating any Jewish ties to Jerusalem, the Temple Mount, and the Western Wall.

Did this not amount to:

  • Showing bias
  • Undermining the UN as an honest broker
  • Rewarding the Palestinians by prejudging the status of Jerusalem

What’s more, Trump’s position was based on fact. The UNESCO vote based on lies, deception and trading on hate of the Jewish state.

The resolution ignored the unique historic connection of Judaism with Jerusalem, negated where the two temples stood for a thousand years and towards which every Jew in the world has prayed for thousands of years.  Even more demeaning and offensive – not only to Israel but to Jews around the world – the resolution omitted the title “Temple Mount”, using instead only the Arabic term for the site, “Haram-al-Sharif”.

The resolution is reminiscent of the Medieval Blood Libel against Jews that led to massacres across Europe for ensuing centuries culminating in the Holocaust.

Bad as this UN resolution was; worse was to follow.

Only a week prior to President Trump’s December 2017 announcement, the General Assembly at the UN in New York voted overwhelmingly to disavow Israeli ties to Jerusalem as part of six anti-Israel resolutions. The vote was 151 in favour, six against and nine abstentions.

Only six countries out of 193 UN member states fully supported Israel’s ties Jerusalem: Canada, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Nauru, the United States, and Israel itself.

If Britain’s Prime Minister Theresa May, France’s President Emmanual Macron, Germany’s Angela Merkel and Russia’s President Vladimir Putin say that the US’s position on Jerusalem prejudices peace efforts, why did they not vote against or even abstain in December General Assembly resolution for the same reason.

  • biased against Israel
  • unable henceforth to act as honest brokers
  • prejudging the status of Jerusalem

They did not because what is good for the goose is not necessary good for the gander because at the root of this drama playing out is not support of Palestinians but deep-rooted hatred of what was once the powerless scattered Jew who is now the proud and powerful Jew, embodied in the State of Israel.

To much of the world, Israel needs to be expunged!

Revelation & Revulsion

Syria

Battling With The Basics. Following months of starvation and battle, Palestinian residents wait for a UN aid ambulance in Yarmouk, Damascus

Explain this rage across the Arab world over one embassy – albeit the USA – moving from a location with a view of the sea to one with a view of the Old City, but when:

  • Over half a million Muslims killed in Syria, many of them Palestinians from Yarmouk, murdered by the Assad regime by bombing, sniper fire, and under torture.

         No rage!

  • Endless daily mass murder by Muslims of Muslims in Yemen and Libya.

          No rage!

  • Palestinians are not allowed to become citizens of Arab countries. Even in Jordan they can no longer become citizens.

          No rage!

  • Palestinians face severe travel restrictions throughout the Arab world. They do not receive passports and their travel documents are only accepted by a few countries.

         No rage!

         No rage!

  • Over 240,000 Palestinians living in Saudi Arabia are not allowed to hold or even apply for Saudi citizenship. Palestinians are the sole foreign group precluded to benefit from a 2004 law passed by Saudi Arabia’s Council of Ministers, entitling expatriates of all nationalities who have resided in the kingdom for ten years to apply for citizenship. Only Palestinians are barred. This is akin to Apartheid against Palestinians.

         No rage!

  • Children born to Palestinians do not receive citizenship in their host countries, violating Article 7 of the ‘Convention on the Rights of the Child.

          No rage!

  • In 2015, Egypt refuses to allow Syrian Palestinians to register with UNHCR, meaning that any who manage to make it to Egypt could not obtain any services or residency permits. There have also been deportations of Palestinians from Syria.

    Syria

    Muslims Murder Muslims. No ‘RAGE’ only resignation as residents of Syria’s besieged Yarmuk Palestinian refugee camp, south of Damascus, crowd a destroyed street during a food distribution led by the UN agency.

         No rage!

  • In Lebanon in 2005, laws were introduced prohibiting foreigners who were not “nationals of a recognized state”, namely Palestinians, from owning property. Those who owned it previously, could not pass it on to their children.

         No rage!

        No rage!

  • In 2013, Lebanon started turning away Palestinian refugees at the border, imposed restrictions on their ability to legally renew their residency papers and in 2015, decreed that Palestinians could only stay in Lebanon for nine hours, and must have visas for a third country.

         No rage!

  • In Kuwait in 1991, 400,000 Palestinians were harassed and forced out of the country.

         No rage!

  • In Libya (1994-1995), 30,000 Palestinians were expelled, dismissed from their jobs and their houses confiscated. Arab countries refused to take in these refugees leaving hundreds stranded in the desert or adrift at sea.

         No rage!

  • In 1994 in Qatar, unlike Arabs from other countries, Palestinians are denied work visas.

         No rage!

  • In Syria, Palestinians have been unable to vote, run for office, or own farmland. Palestinians were denied entry from the fighting in Iraq between 2005 to 2008, and in recent times with the civil war, thousands have been killed in Syria with many starving to death as forces cut off all food and water to the Yarmouk Camp inhabited by Palestinians.

         No rage!

  • In Myanmar the Rohingya Muslims are facing genocide. Those fleeing to Bangladesh amid a military crackdown, have told of horrifying stories of rapes, killings and house burnings, which the Myanmar government claims are “false” and “distorted”.

          No rage!

Of course, there is no rage. Far more important than Muslims being butchered every day across the Middle East into Asia or Palestinians humiliated in most Muslim countries they reside in, all the rage is reserved against the Jewish State which is an anathema – a blot on the landscape that needs to be expunged – today Jerusalem, tomorrow Tel Aviv, the next Haifa.

Just read the Hamas Charter, the same Hamas that recently “reconciled” with the Palestinian Authority. The Charter affirms that Hamas was founded to liberate Palestine, including modern-day Israel, from Israeli occupation and to establish an Islamic state in the area that is now Israel, the West Bank, and the Gaza Strip. There is “no alternative to the liberation of Palestine completely from its sea to its river,” meaning from the Mediterranean Sea to the Jordan River.

Israelis well understand the political topography of the Middle East. What’s more, it feels it is not obliged to commit suicide, and values the USA’s position not only as an act of recognition on the status of Jerusalem but of publicly breaking away from the age-old plague of global anti-Semitism so embedded in the foreign policies of UN members.

This is reason to take cautious comfort while Muslim masses hypocritically rage against the Jewish state

Jews around the world for thousands of years, recite the passage in their prayers, “Next Year In Jerusalem.”

Well, Jews will be in Jerusalem next year and the year after and in the words of one of Israel’s greatest and South African-born diplomats, Abba Eban:

“Israel’s future will be longer than its past”

[ssba]